Right now, it's clearer than ever that the Atlanta Falcons don't have a long-term answer at the quarterback position. Michael Penix Jr. had a promising stretch earlier this season, but things have gone off the rails since then, as after the 35-13 loss to the Chiefs in Week 10, the Falcons are averaging just 10 points per game across the last three weeks.
Atlanta has been stuck in QB purgatory ever since they traded away Matt Ryan, and that was already a half-decade ago now. In that time, we've seen Desmond Ridder, Marcus Mariota, Taylor Heinicke, Kirk Cousins, and Penix start games, and it's clear he doesn't have what it takes to be a franchise guy.
As they embark on a search for their next prospective franchise guy, it makes sense about why Ryan joined the front office, but it also reveals why they hired Kevin Stefanski to be their coach. Stefanski has never hand-picked a QB in the first round of the NFL Draft in seven seasons as a head coach.
The two first-round quarterbacks he's worked with, Penix and Baker Mayfield, were first-round picks drafted by previous coaches and he inherited them, while the QBs he did help draft such as Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders were investments later on in the draft--and the opportunity to draft his own guy was part of why this job jumped out at him.
Now that Penix has thrown six interceptions across the last three games, it's started to become clear he's no more than a bridge guy. This means that the new front office, including Ryan and Stefanski, are more than likely going to do their fair share of homework on the 2027 quarterback class
Ian Cunnningham and the scouting department have been looking closely at guys like CJ Carr, Drew Mestemaker, and Darian Mensah, among others in order to help Stefanski find his guy--which is a storyline to keep monitoring although Penix is most likely still the Week 1 starter next season.
And in doing so, we started evaluating some of the top 2027 QB prospects every week to go over how they performed this weekend--and figure out who is and isn't getting Stefanski's attention. Just like we did last week, let's look at three different prospects from the next generation.
An update on the Atlanta Falcons' search for a new franchise quarterback
Notre Dame QB CJ Carr
Since the Falcons are likely not in Drew Mestemaker range, the QB prospect they have been linked to the most is Notre Dame signal-caller CJ Carr. Carr has thrown 23 touchdowns to just two interceptions this season, and turned in another quality day for the No. 3 Irish against Boston College.
In a 41-7 Notre Dame victory, the run game did most of the heavy lifting. Carr completed 20 of 28 pass attempts for 217 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception. He's near the top of the Heisman leaderboard, but as a prospect, opinions on him are all over the map since he lacks sky-high upside.
He has a lot of good traits, but not a lot of elite ones. CJ Carr is accurate and has good command of an offense, but can he create out of structure? Can he handle the big stage of the College Football Playoff? There are a lot of unknowns, and while there is a lot to like, he is incredibly unproven too.
Here's the thing with CJ Carr. He's a high-floor quarterback who has shades of Brock Purdy in his game, and I can see Kevin Stefanski falling in love with that, especially since he wants a quarterback who plays with sound mechanics and can do what is asked of him within an offense after Penix.
Missouri QB Austin Simmons
One of the more interesting quarterbacks in the country is Missouri's Austin Simmons. Last season, Simmons started out as the starter at Ole Miss, but Trinidad Chambliss stole his job while he was hurt, but he's enjoyed a bit of a breakout at Missouri--who needed a QB after losing Beau Pribula.
Mizzou entered the week as the No. 19 team in the nation, but the issue was that they had to head to Athens to face No. 1 Georgia--and Ian Cunningham was in attendance more than just to get a look at the local talent. He also wanted to get a look at a QB prospect who's rapidly rising up draft boards.
Unfortunately for Simmons, the day didn't go as planned for him. The Tigers lost 48-21 and he completed 17 of 25 passses for 175 yards, three touchdowns, and a pick. To be fair, it was the best defense in the nation, but it's hard to leave this game feeling encouraged by what they saw.
Still, Simmons has great arm talent, is an incredibly smart as a processor (he graduated college at 19), and has elite mobility that makes him a threat out of structure. However, he signed an NIL deal to return to Missouri next season, although he remains eligible to enter the draft if he so chooses.
LSU QB Sam Leavitt
In all likelihood, the Dirty Birds will use one of their four-top 100 picks on a quarterback, but if they don't, that means they're scraping the bottom of the barrel on Day 3. In that scenario, they'd likely see things through with Penix for the remainder of his rookie deal, and nobody wants to see this play out.
If this happens though, a possible option would have been LSU's Sam Leavitt, but his draft stock has taken a major nosedive this season. In their 22-21 loss to No. 6 Texas, Leavitt threw three interceptions, all of which were in Longhorns territory, so he truly lost them the game in this one.
Arch Manning threw three picks too, but at least he came through when it mattered. LSU did not score on their final three drives, and they have a lot of talent. It's been the quarterback play that has them sitting at four losses since Leavitt is tied for the most in the nation with 12 picks in 10 games.
Let me just clarify that I do not see Sam Leavitt as an NFL-caliber quarterback and he isn't worth much more than a seventh-round pick--if that.
