Skip to main content

Falcons' Tommy Rees experiment is starting to look like a Zac Robinson repeat

New OC. Same problems.
ByShane Shoemaker
Oct 11, 2026; Atlanta, Georgia, USA;  Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr. (9) talks to head coach Kevin Stefanski during the second quarter against the Baltimore Ravens at Mercedes-Benz Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-Imagn Images
Oct 11, 2026; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr. (9) talks to head coach Kevin Stefanski during the second quarter against the Baltimore Ravens at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

New head coach. New offensive coordinator. New front office. Same problems.

In Sunday’s 35-13 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs, Atlanta Falcons offensive coordinator Tommy Rees called plays from the sideline instead of the coaches box, where he’d been all season. Kevin Stefanski’s explanation was simple.

“Every week you’re looking at trying to do something that you feel like might help the team and obviously we had some new faces in there … and just felt like maybe get a little bit better communication potentially down on the field,” Stefanski said, per the Associated Press. “Tommy’s done it from upstairs and downstairs, but just trying to do something different.”

There’s just one problem. It’s not different. The Falcons did the exact same thing with Zac Robinson last season under then-head coach Raheem Morris. And the more you look at it, the more Rees’ first year in Atlanta looks like Robinson’s last as play-calling continues to sink this talented offense.

Tommy Rees and Zac Robinson made the same move for the same reason

In September 2025, the Falcons were coming off a 30-0 loss to the Carolina Panthers. Morris responded by moving Robinson from the coaches booth down to the field, which by now is the ultimate sign that a season is cooked.

“We’ll move Zac down to the field to be able to get that little cleaner communication for him and to be able to get [the play] to [Penix] if something does happen,” Morris said at the time, per SI’s Falcon Report.

14 months later, Stefanski moved Rees down to the field for “a little bit better communication.” Same quarterback. Same explanation. Same move. It’s “Groundhog Day,” just without Bill Murray learning anything by the end.

The only real difference is that Rees actually likes the coaches box. Last year, he called it a “great vantage point and in my comfort zone” for calling plays, according to the AJC. So the Falcons took their offensive coordinator out of his comfort zone, and the offense looked just as uncomfortable as it has the last three weeks.

The Falcons opened the game with four straight three-and-outs, the first time they had done that in 26 years. They didn’t pick up a first down until the second quarter and had 117 total yards at halftime. Atlanta went 5-of-16 on third down, and 184 of its 370 yards came in the fourth quarter after the game was decided.

Tommy Rees and Zac Robinson’s offenses have followed the same script

It’s not just the sideline move. The whole arc of these two offenses has been eerily similar.

Both had a brief hot streak that convinced everyone the offense had figured it out. For Robinson, it came right after the move to the sideline, when the Falcons put up their best offensive performance of the season against Washington and then upset Buffalo on Monday Night Football. For Rees, it came when Michael Penix Jr. returned from his ACL injury, and Atlanta scored 80 points in back-to-back wins over Green Bay and New Orleans.

Both were followed by a collapse. After Robinson’s two-game bump, the Falcons lost seven of their next eight games. Since the win over San Francisco in Week 7, Rees’ offense has scored 30 points in three games, including a 16-0 shutout at Tampa Bay.

Both offenses also got embarrassed by Carolina. Robinson’s unit was shut out 30-0 by the Panthers in 2025. Rees’ unit, playing without Penix, lost 34-3 to the Panthers in Week 2, the worst home loss in Mercedes-Benz Stadium history.

And in both cases, what was the brilliant move? Move the play-caller closer to the field. Why, as punishment?

The common denominator for the Falcons isn’t the offensive coordinator

Stefanski said Rees will stay on as the play-caller. But when asked about his confidence in his hand-picked offensive coordinator, he didn’t exactly give him a ringing endorsement.

“Yeah, listen, we need to be better,” Stefanski said. “All the above, myself included.”

Hiring Rees was one of Stefanski’s first major moves in Atlanta, and it’s hard to say it was a popular one with Falcons fans. Last season in Cleveland, Stefanski handed play-calling duties to Rees when the Browns were 2-6. Cleveland, which was juggling rookie quarterbacks Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders, went 3-6 the rest of the way to finish 5-12. Rees still followed Stefanski to Atlanta. So did the quarterback problems.

Now, with the Falcons at 3-7, Stefanski doesn’t seem keen on taking away Rees’ play-calling duties just yet. When asked after the loss whether Rees would remain the play-caller, Stefanski simply said, “Yes.”

But if two different offensive coordinators, under two different head coaches, are running into the same problems with the same quarterback, maybe the play-caller isn’t the issue.

Robinson had Penix, Bijan Robinson and Drake London. Rees has Penix, Bijan Robinson and Drake London. Robinson’s offense struggled with consistency in the passing game, and so has Rees’. Over his last three games, Penix has completed 51 of 98 passes for 573 yards with one touchdown and six interceptions. That’s a 52% completion rate, well below the 59.6% he completed over his first two NFL seasons and a far cry from the 73.3% he completed in his first two starts this year.

Even the locker room doesn’t seem to blame Rees. Left guard Matthew Bergeron came to his defense after the loss.

“I love Tommy to death, so that’s not the issue,” Bergeron said.

He might be right. Six of Atlanta’s seven offensive penalties against Kansas City were on the offensive line, and right tackle Jawaan Taylor was tipping plays with his stance. None of that gets fixed by changing where the offensive coordinator stands, or who’s holding the call sheet.

At this point, the last eight years of Falcons football have felt like the “Fast & Furious” franchise. Every installment brings a new city, a new villain and a new face or two in the cast. Yet the results are bad movies guided by bad performances.

Zac Robinson was one installment. Tommy Rees is the latest. And until the Falcons figure out the quarterback position, each sequel is going to look exactly the same.

Add us as a preferred source on Google