It's fairly obvious that Michael Penix Jr. entered the season with a lot on the line, and that's only continued as the season has gone on. The Atlanta Falcons want to give him a chance to prove himself, but that also doesn't mean they're going to hitch his wagon to him for the next half-decade.
The Falcons are in a position where they need to figure out what they want to do with him. They can either treat him like a long-term franchise QB or draft a new signal-caller in the 2027 NFL Draft, which would allow Kevin Stefanski to handpick his quarterback for the first time in his head coaching career.
Penix has a lot on the line this season, as not only is he playing for his future as a starter, he's playing for a long-term contract extension. The former top-10 pick is eligible for a new deal this offseason, and there has been widespread debate about whether or not Atlanta should actually pay him.
Early returns this season have been promising, or at least that was the case until Week 8. In Sunday's 16-0 loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Penix threw four interceptions and clearly didn't have it. He was throwing ducks all day, so he could've had a five-interception day just like Matt Ryan did in 2012.
It was the worst start of his NFL career, as he accrued a career-worst 8.2 passer rating, but it did come in a torrential downpour in Tampa Bay where he had no business throwing the football as much as he did. But the conditions are no excuse given he was the NFC Offensive Player of the Week last game. It was a brutal step backward after things were finally headed in the right direction.
What does a QB extension meter actually mean for Michael Penix Jr.?
Unlike some of his fellow QBs from the 2024 Draft class, whether or not the Dirty Birds should actually pay the 26-year-old is more up in the air. It's not like Caleb Williams or Drake Maye where it's a guarantee, and frankly, every week is going to be a new audition to the front office about his future.
There have been plenty of moments this season where Penix has looked like either a franchise QB or shown flashes of possibly becoming one, but there has also been a lot of inconsistency that makes it a confusing gamble. Eventually a decision is going to have to be made though.
So with that in mind, I decided to start a new series: a QB extension meter that should determine how confident the Falcons should be in extending Michael Penix Jr., since the way things go under center will ultimately decide the next direction Kevin Stefanski and Ian Cunningham take this franchise.
This is the next step in the rebuild. You can't afford to get it wrong. So I created a scale from 1 (absolutely don't extend him) to 10 (let's break the bank) to determine how confident this front office should feel on paying him.
Rating | Meaning | Description |
|---|---|---|
10 | Let's break the bank | Overpay to keep him |
9 | Blank check | He deserves a real payday. |
8 | Things are trending up. | He's playing like the guy. |
7 | If this is sustained, yes. | Consistency confirms it. |
6 | If the price is right. | Only on a team-friendly deal. |
5 | Maybe on a short-term deal | No more than 2 years. |
4 | Don't worry about it now. | Keep evaluating him until later on in his rookie deal . |
3 | Only if he's a backup | Not for starter money |
2 | It's increasingly unlikely. | I'd rather draft someone else. |
1 | Absolutely not | Let someone else pay him |
So without further ado, let's dive into the confidence meter and see how much things took a hit after a brutal performance on Sunday.
Does Michael Penix Jr. deserve a contract extension from the Falcons?
If you had asked me before the week, I would have placed Penix anywhere from tiers 6 to 8. He bought himself that much goodwill against the 49ers and since returning to the starting lineup that there wasn't much doubt here since he's started to turn it on in an offense catered to his strengths.
However, the Bucs loss could not have been a bigger step in the wrong direction. It exposed many of the red flags in his game, as his decision-making was putrid. And given his best trait this season has been taking care of the football, it's worrisome to see what a good defensive gameplan can do to him.
I think this performance was an anomaly between the rain and Todd Bowles having the Dirty Birds' number, but it's not that simple. There were too many instances of the Washington product making a boneheaded decision, as there was a good dozen passes where he had no business throwing them.
The Verdict: 2
Truthfully, Michael Penix Jr. is too inconsistent to warrant a new extension currently. He isn't good out of structure, he struggles under pressure, and he isn't a great processor. The arm talent is stellar, but that is the only elite trait he has. So while I want to believe in him starting QBs go for between $30 and $60 million a year on extensions, he clearly doesn't deserve that money now or anytime soon.
It's not like they're going to bench him or anything, because they don't have a better option, but Atlanta also wants to see things through. One awful start in these conditions is not bench-worthy, but with the way he played on Sunday, it's the first time all year it looked unlikely he was a franchise guy.
He can also be placed in 4, as you can continue evaluating him and see how things change for the rest of the season before figuring out if you want to draft a QB early on in 2027, and if not, maybe 2028. He's still under contract for two more years, so there isn't really much of a rush to sign him.
Penix is the best option right now (at least for the rest of 2026), but that can change fast. I can't imagine the Falcons hired Kevin Stefanski to not let him pick his guy. so doing homework on upcoming quarterback prospects will be imperative until he starts stacking good performances.
This entire regime has no connection to Michael Penix Jr., and given confidence is waning coming off of a brutal start in Tampa Bay, he has to re-gain some goodwill and bounce back with a big day against the Bengals in Madrid before he digs himself in a deeper hole he can't get out of.
Add us as a preferred source on Google