Skip to main content

Michael Penix Jr.'s struggles are giving Falcons a major dose of NFL Draft regret

The what-if game is back.
ByJason Kandel
Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr.
Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Atlanta Falcons drafted Michael Penix Jr. with the eighth pick in the 2024 NFL Draft thinking they could turn a guy with elite arm strength into a legit franchise quarterback. It was a bold play weeks after signing Kirk Cousins, and one Terry Fontenot had to explain to Arthur Blank in the war room.

Penix was coming off of a season in which he was the Heisman Trophy finalist and led Washington to the national championship. However, everything we saw from him in college has failed to translate to the NFL, as not only has he struggled to stay healthy, he has a brutal 7-13 record through 20 starts.

In the 35-13 loss to the Chiefs in Week 10, it took Penix 43 attempts to throw for 286 passing yards and threw his sixth interception in the last three games. It's obvious at this point he isn't a franchise guy since he can't handle pressure and is unable to escape the pocket. So he better kiss his chances of a long-term extension goodbye.

At the time, most Falcons fans badly wanted a pass-rusher on Day 1, and there were three they were linked to: Jared Verse, Laiatu Latu, and Dallas Turner. And while Latu was the one who came the closest to being the pick, Turner was also popular in rumors--and he's in the midst of a great year.

The Atlanta Falcons should have drafted Dallas Turner over Michael Penix Jr. in 2024

Turner was drafted nine picks later by the Minnesota Vikings, who selected him with the 17th pick. And while he got off to a slow start as a rookie, the flashes were there. He's improved every year, as he jumped up to eight sacks last year, while Year 3 has seen him take the biggest leap of his career.

While Michael Penix Jr. has looked lost out there and no more than a bridge QB this season, Dallas Turner has enjoyed a major breakout season. He already tied his 2025 sack total of eight, but he's looked like a perennial All-Pro guy for what's undoubtedly been the best defense in football.

The 23-year-old has been the glue of Brian Flores' defense, as only Will Anderson has more sacks than him this season--and he's also near the top of the league in TFLs.

In Minnesota's 30-10 thrashing of the Green Bay Packers on Sunday, Turner was again all over the field. He amassed a sack, a QB hit, two tackles for loss, and a key fumble recovery on an aborted snap that set the Vikings up deep in Green Bay territory and helped them extend their lead to 20 in Kirk Cousins' first game back in purple.

The only caveat to this what-if is that if the Dirty Birds had selected Dallas Turner, they likely wouldn't have drafted Jalon Walker and James Pearce Jr., but that's a trade-off that'd be well worth it at this point, since not only does he look like a future star, anything would be better than what they got.

As we take a trip in the Hot Tub Time Machine, we see the Falcons could have several different ways with the eighth overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, and Dallas Turner would have been one of the best alternatives to Michael Penix Jr.--since Atlanta may be looking to draft his successor this spring.

Add us as a preferred source on Google