Skip to main content

Kevin Stefanski deserves more than one season to clean up the Falcons’ mess

Give the guy a shot.
ByShane Shoemaker
Oct 18, 2026; Atlanta, Georgia, USA;  Atlanta Falcons head coach Kevin Stefanski looks on during the second quarter against the Chicago Bears at Mercedes-Benz Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-Imagn Images
Oct 18, 2026; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Atlanta Falcons head coach Kevin Stefanski looks on during the second quarter against the Chicago Bears at Mercedes-Benz Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Suffice it to say, sitting at 3-7 heading into the bye week, this isn’t exactly the season anyone involved with the Atlanta Falcons was hoping for. What may be difficult to figure out is, what were the realistic expectations for the 2026 season in the first place under new leadership?

Two new faces and one familiar constructed the Falcons new leadership this season, with new general manager Ian Cunningham, president of football Matt Ryan and head coach Kevin Stefanski.

But the results so far have yielded more of what has become the Falcons’ norm over the last eight years instead of any real signs of progress, at least through 10 games. And as of now, it’s easy to point fingers at Stefanski, even if not all of the scrutiny is warranted.

Should Kevin Stefanski be on the hot seat after just 10 games in Atlanta?

So, does that mean Stefanski is already on the hot seat in the middle of Year 1? Well, he didn’t make CBS Sports’ Carter Bahns’ top 10 list entering Week 11:

  1. Aaron Glenn, New York Jets
  2. Shane Steichen, Indianapolis Colts
  3. Brian Schottenheimer, Dallas Cowboys
  4. Jim Harbaugh, Los Angeles Chargers
  5. Nick Sirianni, Philadelphia Eagles
  6. Dan Quinn, Washington Commanders
  7. Todd Bowles, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
  8. Robert Saleh, Tennessee Titans
  9. Kellen Moore, New Orleans Saints
  10. DeMeco Ryans, Houston Texans

Yes, that’s former Falcons coach Dan Quinn at No. 6, still trying to keep his job in Washington. And two NFC South coaches, Bowles and Moore, made the cut too. My goodness what a disaster of a division.

Of the 10 coaches listed, every one except Saleh has at least one full season under his belt at his current job. Sirianni is in his sixth season in Philadelphia, and Bowles is in his fifth in Tampa Bay.

I don’t doubt there are plenty of Falcons fans who would be totally fine with telling Stefanski to beat it after just one season. After all, his hire was met with mixed reactions in the first place. But it was nowhere near as questionable as the coach he came in to replace, Raheem Morris, who was fired after just two seasons. However, I’d say it’s probably a bit unfair to call it quits on Stefanski so soon.

Falcons’ last eight seasons left Kevin Stefanski a mess to clean up

Look, let’s get real: sometimes you have to make a mess to clean things up. Granted, what Kevin Stefanski walked into was already a mess, but he, Cunningham and Ryan have their work cut out for them, having to fix nearly a decade’s worth of ineptitude that started in the front office and trickled down to the sidelines.

I think all three of those guys walked into the building like Jeff Goldblum in the first “Jurassic Park” and said, “That is one big pile of…”

Here’s what that pile looks like. Since the Falcons’ last playoff appearance in 2017, they’ve gone 55-78 over eight seasons without a single winning record. They’ve cycled through three general managers (Thomas Dimitroff, Terry Fontenot and now Cunningham) and five head coaching tenures.

It started with Dan Quinn, who took Atlanta to Super Bowl LI and won 10 games the following season. He was fired after an 0-5 start in 2020, along with Dimitroff. Morris finished that season as the interim coach and went 4-7.

Then came Arthur Smith, a first-time head coach who went 7-10 in all three of his seasons before being fired. And after that, the Falcons went back to Morris, the same guy they passed over in 2021. Before he was hired in 2024, Morris’ resume as a head coach consisted of a 17-31 record in three seasons with Tampa Bay and that 4-7 interim stint in Atlanta. He went 8-9 in each of his two seasons and was fired in January.

If Morris was the right guy, why wasn’t he the right guy in 2021?

Stefanski not only had to come in knowing all of this, there was likely some sort of unwritten agreement that he’d get a few mulligans. Even with the talent already on this year’s roster, there were still enough glaring holes that any realistic Falcons fan knew it could be Year 9 without a playoff berth.

The biggest reason Stefanski gets a mulligan in 2026 is the quarterback position. From the jump, this year’s team was put in a disastrous position at quarterback, having to first rework Kirk Cousins’ massive contract in the offseason, then cut him. That left them with a banged-up Michael Penix Jr., which led them to sign Tua Tagovailoa, only because the Dolphins are paying him. Atlanta signed Tagovailoa for the veteran minimum of $1.215 million, while Miami is on the hook for the remaining $52.785 million of his 2026 salary and an NFL-record $99.2 million in dead money.

By the time the season started, Tagovailoa couldn’t even make his first start, Penix said he wasn’t ready, and next thing you know, Cooper Rush is starting. Then, once Penix decided he was good to go, he lit it up for two games, teasing everyone, probably even Stefanski, into thinking he was the guy. Since then, he’s got everyone making early plans for the draft in April.

It is curious, however, that Stefanski chose to take this job knowing he was likely going to run into the same quarterback problem he dealt with for nearly his entire tenure in Cleveland. In six seasons with the Browns, Stefanski started 13 different quarterbacks, including seven over his final two seasons. My only guess is that he knew he’d probably get the chance to find his quarterback in the draft over the next few years, or he’d luck out with Penix.

How long of a leash should Kevin Stefanski get with the Falcons?

The question now becomes how long of a leash he will have.

His track record in Cleveland cuts both ways. Stefanski went 45-56 in the regular season with the Browns, made the playoffs twice and won AP Coach of the Year both of those seasons, in 2020 and 2023. From 2020 to 2023, he gave Cleveland its best four-year winning percentage since the late 1980s. But the Browns went a combined 8-26 over his final two seasons, and he was fired in January.

And it doesn’t help that the Browns are doing just fine without him. Under first-year coach Todd Monken, Cleveland is 6-4 and has already topped last season’s win total.

Still, I’d say the two-time Coach of the Year has earned at least through Year 3, especially with what should still be a winnable NFC South. Two of his division rivals’ coaches are on the hot seat list, and the division-leading Panthers are just 4-5. Every team in the division has its own question marks, and nobody is running away with anything.

Kevin Stefanski’s first goal is getting back to the playoffs and ending the drought. But to do that, he has to find his franchise quarterback first. And if that means drafting one in 2027, the real question is how much time he’ll get to develop a rookie before the clock runs out on him, too.

Add us as a preferred source on Google