After months upon months of speculation, the Atlanta Falcons' quarterback battle is officially over.
Yesterday, they officially named Tua Tagovailoa the starter over Michael Penix Jr. for Sunday's season opener against the Pittsburgh Steelers while Penix will be a healthy inactive--as Cooper Rush will be the backup QB come Week 1. But it doesn't feel like this competition ever truly had a resolution.
Technically, Penix never lost the battle--and may still win the war. They opted to start the healthier of the two QBs given he was only cleared for full contact until two weeks ago. That isn't enough time or 11-or-11 reps to feel comfortable starting him Week 1 coming off a torn ACL given his injury history.
But for as weird as it sounds, Michael Penix Jr.'s benching could actually be a blessing in disguise for him in the long run.
Michael Penix Jr. will be the starter as soon as he returns to the field
For starters, however long he's on the bench will offer him ample opportunity to get more practice reps in--and get healthier--before the Falcons throw him into the fire as QB1. Because as soon as he gets back this job should be his unless Tua Tagovailoa suddenly turns into prime Patrick Mahomes
Michael Penix Jr. says he doesn’t feel ready to play quite yet, but that he’s “real close.” pic.twitter.com/YHnyC4lAoC
— Joe Patrick (@JoePatrick) September 7, 2026
Penix even said at the podium yesterday that he isn't where he wants to be, but "really close" to returning, further confirming the notion that this wasn't a talent issue, but a health one. He even told Kevin Stefanski the same thing--which is no surprise given he was unable to play in the preseason.
And speaking of Stefanski, it's particularly telling that he (nor the team) was willing to commit to a starter beyond Week 1 because of the wild card that is Michael Penix Jr.'s health. Upon first glance, it seems like the Falcons are only rolling with Tua to warm up the seat until the 26-year-old can return.
While there's a chance Tagovailoa runs away with the starting job if he capitalizes on the scenery change, that seems highly unlikely. He'd basically need to return to Pro Bowl form or lead the Falcons to wins, and after what we saw from him earlier this summer, it doesn't seem like he's capable of playing at a high level anymore.
Truthfully, Michael Penix Jr. could start as early as the home opener in Week 2 or potentially spend the first month on the shelf. It all depends on how safe they play it. But even though the Falcons didn't name him QB1 to start the season due to his health, he should still start most of the games he's healthy for.
So even though the former top-10 pick is entering a make-or-break season, Tua Tagovailoa struggling makes it much easier to hand the reins over to him once he's completely healthy compared to vice versa if he struggled--and will make it that they no longer have to rush him back.
Add us as a preferred source on Google