One of the most talented quarterback classes in recent memory entered the league during the 2024 NFL Draft. However, it seems like the Atlanta Falcons didn’t get the best deal out of their first-round QB…
With the eighth pick, the Falcons drafted Michael Penix Jr., meaning he was the fourth quarterback taken behind Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels and Drake Maye. Both Bo Nix and J.J. McCarthy were also selected in Round 1, creating a very loaded group of 6 signal-callers taken in the first 12 picks.
However, some of these QBs have proven to be genuine franchise players, while Penix hasn’t. His future as the starter is in serious jeopardy, and always good to look at what-ifs in this business, so let's see where he stacks up with the rest of the quarterbacks drafted in the first round in 2024.
Ranking Michael Penix Jr. and the 2024 QB class off their careers so far
1. Drake Maye – New England Patriots (Pick 3)
After an impressive rookie season, Drake Maye exploded onto the scene in 2025. He amassed 4394 passing yards, 31 touchdowns and just 8 interceptions, completing 72% of his passes to take the Patriotsto the Super Bowl and finishing as the runner-up in MVP voting behind Matthew Stafford.
This was backed up by a solid 2026 season so far, where he has thrown for 2,330 yards and 18 touchdowns in 10 games. However he's also thrown 11 interceptions and is likely out for the rest of the season after fracturing his ankle against the Detroit Lions in Week 10.
New England has found their franchise QB, and Maye looks to be one of the best young players in the entire league despite the regression from 2025.
2. Caleb Williams – Chicago Bears (Pick 1)
Williams had a tough rookie season, however he has developed incredibly well since Ben Johnson came to Chicago. He threw for 3942 yards and 27 touchdowns in 2025, taking the Bears all the way to an 11-6 record and their first playoff win in years.
The former Heisman Trophy winner hasn’t been at his best in 2026 due to a hamstring injury that saw him miss three games earlier this year. But he has looked very comfortable in Johnson’s system. When he's at his best, he's one of the most fun-to-watch talents in the league--and that's saying a lot.
3. Jayden Daniels – Washington Commanders (Pick 2)
If just looking at their best season, Daniels could easily be at the top of this list. He threw for an incredible 3568 yards and 25 touchdowns in his rookie season, along with adding 891 rushing yards. This helped take Washington all the way to the NFC Championship Game in Year 1 under ex-Falcons coach Dan Quinn.
However, Daniels has suffered from multiple injuries, and his durability. The former Offensive Rookie of the Year has only played seven games in 2025 and has only made seven appearances this season. But when he's on the field, we know how dynamic he's capable of being.
4. Bo Nix – Denver Broncos (Pick 12)
Bo Nix probably doesn’t get enough credit for all he has accomplished with the Denver Broncos. He has thrown for 9436 yards, 65 touchdowns and 27 interceptions in 43 career starts. And if it wasn't for his ankle injury in the playoffs, we most likely see the Broncos repping the AFC in the Super Bowl.
It’s always good to stay injury free, perform consistently and give your team a real chance to win each week. So while some like to say
5. J.J. McCarthy – New York Giants (Pick 10)
This is where it gets a bit tricky. J.J. McCarthy missed his entire rookie season with a knee injury and struggled when given his chance in Minnesota. It seemed like Kevin O'Connell never really wanted him, and it never clicked.
This resulted in him being traded to the Giants in September. However, he has improved, throwing for 915 yards with a 90 passer rating in five games--and has stabilized the offense since Jaxson Dart got hurt..
Does he really have more achievements than Penix? No. However, he is younger, has less NFL experience and has been given a clean slate in New York, that aside for his ugly two interceptions in crunch time on primetime Week 10, he's taken advantage of the second lease on life as a starter.
6. Michael Penix Jr. – Atlanta Falcons (Pick 8)
Finally, we have Michael Penix Jr. in the cellar. This might seem a little harsh, as he has probably performed better than McCarthy throughout their careers.
However, Penix has thrown for 4,487 yards, 22 touchdowns and 13 interceptions in 20 career starts. These aren’t terrible numbers, however they are pretty poor compared to the other QBs in this class--especially since his hot start is firmly in the rearview mirror.
His recent performances have also not helped. He threw three touchdowns in both his games against Chicago and San Francisco, however completely collapsed against Tampa, throwing foue interceptions - one of his worst performances of the season.
He then threw for just 162 yards in Madrid against Cincinnati, and it took him 43 pass attempts to throw for 286 yards in Week 10 against Kansas City. This means he has thrown six interceptions in the last three games after throwing just one (on his opening drive) across his first five starts.
Penix has proven that he can perform at a high level. He has great arm talent and can throw some incredible passes when he is comfortable. However, he is 26 years old, has suffered multiple major injuries and hasn’t showed the consistency that'd be expected from someone picked in the top 10.
All we know is that by looking at this draft class, it's obvious the Atlanta Falcons need to see more from Michael Penix Jr. before they crown him their franchise savior.
