Skip to main content

Falcons lit $54 million on fire with wasteful Kyle Pitts contract extension

ByNick Halden
Nov 8, 2026; Madrid, ESP;  Atlanta Falcons tight end Kyle Pitts Sr. (8) reacts after making a reception against the Cincinnati Bengals during the second quarter at Bernabeu Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Nov 8, 2026; Madrid, ESP; Atlanta Falcons tight end Kyle Pitts Sr. (8) reacts after making a reception against the Cincinnati Bengals during the second quarter at Bernabeu Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Atlanta Falcons were put into an undeniably tough position with tight end Kyle Pitts this past offseason after the pass catcher had a productive season. One that demanded the Falcons at least consider the re-signing landing on a three-year $54 million pact that answered any questions about the future.

This was on the heels of a 2025 season where Pitts offered 928 receiving yards and five touchdowns in what was viewed as a bounce-back season season from a player that has been an enternal question mark and source of frustration.

Fast forward 10 weeks into the 2026 season and Atlanta already has seven losses on the year and Pitts often is missing from the offense. The tight end has 270 receiving yards and four touchdowns with much of this production coming in garbage time when the game is already well out of reach, a frustration that perfectly defines the roller coaster the Falcons have signed up for.

The Atlanta Falcons should regret signing Kyle Pitts to a contract extension

Calling the contract extension a mistake 10 games into the 2026 season isn't dramatic, but accurate for a team not built to win now. Pitts isn't being utilized up to his talent level and whether this is a matter of effort, scheme, or simply a combination of both is up for debate.

What cannot be argued is how frustrating it is to realize Atlanta is signed up for an additional two years of attempting to talk themselves into the former top-five pick. One moment Pitts can be leaping and making a perfect catch exploding for a big play, only to follow this with three weeks of making fans completely forget he is on the field.

Falcons made a colossal mistake opting to extend Kyle Pitts this summer

Looking back it is money that should've been saved for a push after what will be a failed 2026 season. The Falcons waved the white flag ahead of this past week's game after trading away Jessie Bates and parting ways with starting center Ryan Neuzil. The loss on Sunday simply cemented another lost year while highlighting the inconsistent investment that is Kyle Pitts.

The best season of the 26-year-old's career when it comes to total yardage remains Matt Ryan's final season with the team. A telling state that suggests the legendary quarterback (and now president of football) was propping up a flawed player, one that has left reason to question his ability to play through the whistle and show up each and every week.

It will be interesting to watch whether Atlanta explores an escape from the deal looking at trade possibilties or remains content to be attatched to an obvious frustration. For Pitts, it is yet another year of underwhelming production that cannot be laid at the feet of the subpar quarterback situation.

Even if Michael Penix Jr. is not delivering consistent football, star players find ways to show up. Drake London and Bijan Robinson have both proven this repeatedly leaving no excuse for Pitts, and the $54 million investment the front office spent as a clear mistake that is likely to be revisited down the road.

Add us as a preferred source on Google