Skip to main content

Kirk Cousins' return to Minnesota helped a Michael Penix Jr. realization sink in

Absence makes the heart grow fonder.
ByJason Kandel
  Minnesota Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins
Minnesota Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

While it's true that Kirk Cousins is the worst free-agent signing in Atlanta Falcons history, it's unfair to place all of the blame on him. Just weeks after he was signed, the Falcons drafted Michael Penix Jr., and Cousins was lighting things up before playing through a shoulder injury that derailed his season.

That was basically setting him up to fail, since his time as the starting quarterback would be on a clock. And that's what happened, as Atlanta replaced him with Penix as the starter by Week 16-- a decision that continues to age just as horribly as the decision to draft him in the first place has.

The sad part with Penix is that he displayed promise before tearing his ACL, but no consistency. After he went down last season, Cousins led them to four straight wins to end last season, yet he was still released to get his cap hit off the books. From there, he signed with the Las Vegas Raiders, where he turned back the clock with them before getting traded to the Minnesota Vikings at the trade deadline.

So this weekend marked Cousins' first game as a Viking since 2023, and it went swimmingly. Minnesota traveled to Lambeau Field and beat the Green Bay Packers 30-10. With the win, the Vikings improved to 7-2 as they finally have the QB play to make their offense look competent.

And while his statistical stat-line doesn't jump off the page. the Falcons are now facing an ugly truth: they let the wrong quarterback go this past offseason.

The Atlanta Falcons messed up choosing Kirk Cousins over Michael Penix Jr.

The 38-year-old completed 21 of 31 passes for 207 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception in Week 10. That's a quality day for a quarterback who was traded in the middle of the season. But that's exactly why he was dealt: he knows Kevin O'Connell's system and is familiar with these receivers.

Meanwhile, Michael Penix Jr.'s Week 10 performance was anything but encouraging. As the Dirty Birds suffered a 35-13 loss at the hands of the Kansas City Chiefs, the offense stalled. Penix threw his sixth pick in the last three games and it took him 43 pass attempts to throw for 286 yards.

Here's the thing: Kirk Cousins has proven time and time again that he's a quality starter who shows nice command of an offense. He turned back the clock in Las Vegas to help a team that previously had the No. 1 pick show signs of life on offense, and now he'll lead the Vikings to the playoffs.

Cousin ranks fifth in passing yards and second in passing touchdowns in 2026.. He's a guy you can win with and has proven to do what an offense asks of him. The former top-10 pick has never shown that same command, and frankly, the Falcons should be on the hunt for a new franchise QB this draft.

For a Falcons team looking for any sort of consistency at quarterback, it stings to know they could've had Kirk Cousins rather than being stuck with a Michael Penix Jr. experiment that clearly isn't working.

Add us as a preferred source on Google