Skip to main content

The core difference between Bijan Robinson and Jahmyr Gibbs became clear in Week 10

ByJason Kandel
Atlanta Falcons running back Bijan Robinson
Atlanta Falcons running back Bijan Robinson | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

One of the most heated debates among football fans is about who is the best running back in the league. Some think it's Bijan Robinson while others think it's Jahmyr Gibbs, and given they're the two highest-paid RBs in NFL history, it's hard to debate that anyone else is even in the conversation.

And for as much as the Atlanta Falcons fans out there want to say it's Bijan, Gibbs is giving him a real run for his money. After Week 10, the Lions star leads the league in both rushing yards (1,000) and rushing touchdowns (11), as his first season as a true feature back has gone far better than expected.

In the Lions' Week 35-10 victory over the New England Patriots in Munich, he carried the football 22 times for 153 yards and two touchdowns, but it didn't end there. He also recorded seven receptions for a team-high 99 yards, including a 50-yard catch-and-run that was nothing short of incredible.

For all of my fantasy managers out there, he more than likely won you your week before the 1:00 p.m. slate even started. In PPR leagues, the guy put up 44.2 fantasy points, and 252 scrimmage yards. And while we've seen stuff like this from No. 7 before, we haven't this side of him at all this season really.

A lackluster Atlanta Falcons' offense is holding Bijan Robinson back

The unfortunate part about the best RB debate is that elite backs get more shine when they're playing on a playoff team, and only one of these guys is. Jahmyr Gibbs plays for a 7-2 Lions team that is atop the NFC North standings, while Bijan's Falcons are 3-7 and suffering in a weak NFC South.

The Lions have more stable QB play out of Jared Goff, a rebuilt offensive line, and elite weapons like Amon-Ra St. Brown, Jameson Williams, and Sam LaPorta to take pressure off of him. It's impossible to stack the box on him, and for a back who has such elite explosiveness, that's a dangerous combo.

Obviously Atlanta still has other talented weapons, but Drake London and Kyle Pitts aren't as good as St. Brown and LaPorta. Only the Chiefs and 49ers average more yards of offense per game than Detroit, but Gibbs gets much more consistent usage. He has more rushing attempts and has been more productive as a pass-catcher since Goff is actually willing to check the ball down to him.

Unlike Gibbs, he has to deal with inconsistent QB play from Michael Penix Jr. and subpar play-calling from Tommy Rees. Moreover, it doesn't help that the offensive line has been horrible, especially in run blocking, because an unstable situation is proving that the Falcons are actively failing Bijan Robinson. This awful situation is holding him back from people thinking he's better than his fellow 2023 draftee.

It's a complete travesty that Robinson has never played in a playoff game, since the Dirty Birds are wasting a generational talent. Meanwhile, Jahmyr Gibbs and the Lions are showing us the blueprint of how to get the most out of an elite running back--so he's earned that best RB title since he plays for a winning team.

Add us as a preferred source on Google