The biggest variable in determining the Atlanta Falcons' quarterback situation is Michael Penix Jr.'s health. If he was cleared for full contact by the start of training camp, the Falcons would have embarked on a quarterback competition between Penix and Tua Tagovailoa, but that wasn't the case.
It came out during the opening day of training camp that the 2024 first-round pick was still four weeks away from being cleared for 11-on-11s, but he's still been participating in 7-on-7s, where he's started to look a lot better in recent days--but as of right now, it's not enough to feel comfortable.
Basically, the Penix update ended the Falcons' QB battle before it could ever begin. Tua Tagovailoa starting in Week 1 has started to become more possible with each passing day, and the more time it takes the third-year quarterback to get cleared, the more inevitable these updates will become.
But this doesn't tell the whole story:
The narratives surrounding Michael Penix Jr.'s rehab aren't all true
ESPN's Jeremy Fowler, who visited Falcons training camp for Saturday's practice, gave a pretty unflattering update about the former top-10 pick. Fowler reported that he's "still weeks away" from 11-man work, which doesn't bode well for his chances of suiting up against the Steelers in Week 1.
"Michael Penix Jr. is inching (somewhat) closer to full clearance from his ACL surgery, but he's still weeks away from 11-man work," Fowler wrote. "The team does not know yet whether he'll be able to play in a preseason game. He did a lot when I was in attendance Saturday, completing four of eight passes in 7-on-7."
Here's what Fowler's report doesn't tell you: he's been throwing since mid-March and is further along than even the Falcons have expected. He's been participating in 7-on-7 since OTAs, so while he may not be 100% yet, you don't want to rush a player back when they have the injury history Penix has.
Knowing it's the Washington product's third ACL tear, the Dirty Birds are actively taking it slow with his recovery. Kevin Stefanski has revealed the team wants to be cautious as to not risk re-injury, but too many people are acting like Atlanta is handling this wrong when they're objectively right to be worried.
Michael Penix Jr. has said that his focus is on getting healthy until he's fully cleared--then he'll focus on winning the starting job. Why are we crucifying this kid for putting his rehab first? The only way he even has a chance to start over Tagovailoa is if he doesn't try to accelerate the process.
The media is propping up this narrative that Penix has no chance of being cleared anytime soon, and there is no QB battle here. And while that may be true, thinking Tua will hold onto the starting job all season after what we saw from him in 2025 is delusional--even if the scenery change will help him.
Yes, even if Michael Penix Jr.'s future is in jeopardy, the Falcons have more incentive to start him over Tua. They have more investment in him, and this isn't a Patrick Mahomes or Daniel Jones situation. The only option here is to be patient, and the national media is known not to be very good at that.
The Falcons won't rush naming a starter, so while Tua Tagovailoa is the favorite, nothing is certain.
Add us as a preferred source on Google