Skip to main content

Tommy Rees and Michael Penix Jr. are becoming a nightmare pairing for the Falcons

Everyone is to blame.
ByJason Kandel
Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr.
Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Across the last couple of weeks, the Atlanta Falcons' offense has completely unraveled after a hot start upon Michael Penix Jr.'s return to the lineup. In his first five starts, they went 3-2 and averaged 31 points per game, but across their three-game losing streak, the offensive output has evaporated.

The Falcons are averaging just 10 points per game across the last three weeks, and Penix has thrown six interceptions across that timeframe. His calling card early on was taking care of the football, but now he's failed to do so--and it doesn't help that he's immobile and gets flustered when pressured.

Some fans are blaming the former top-10 pick and others are blaming offensive coordinator Tommy Rees for the lack of production. But the fact of the matter is that they're both to blame for Atlanta's recent struggles, as while the QB play of late has been a legit abomination, so has the play-calling.

When I was in high school, we learned about relationships between organisms: mutualism (both benefit), parasitism (one benefits, one is harmed), and commensalism (one benefits, one is unaffected). But the relationship between Penix and Rees fits none of these categories. Neither of them benefit from having the other around, and they both actively make the other look worse.

It's showing shades of the Arthur Smith-Desmond Ridder pairing in 2022 and 2023 where the Falcons were led by two different incompetent people and they each made the offense look like a disaster in a different way. It's weirdly paradoxical, and it's clear at this point that the fit isn't there between them.

Michael Penix Jr. and Tommy Rees are making each other look worse

The issues with this Atlanta offense are cyclical. Tommy Rees isn't able to run the offense the way he wants to because of Penix's limitations, while the young OC hasn't elevated his young QB or made his life any easier. In fact, they've both made each other's lives harder.

Rees wants to pound the rock, but you can't do that against stacked boxes where Bijan Robinson has no room due to bad OL play. And in turn, he's had to rely on Michael Penix Jr.'s arm more, and to do so, he keeps calling all these quick screens due to a lack of faith in him to convert in any other way.

The 26-year-old can't see the field well, he can't escape the pocket, and he continues to either miss the throw or doesn't see open guys. So of course play-calling suggests a lack of trust in him. In Week 10 against the Chiefs, Penix completed just 23 of his 43 pass attempts (53.4%) while 188 of his 286 passing yards game in the fourth quarter down by multiple scores. But the run game has faltered and they have not used Bijan enough to take pressure off of him--so that part falls on the OC.

The first rule of being a coach is that you want to get your young QB in a rhythm and get their confidence up early on in a game, yet the Dirty Birds fail that test. A lot of Penix's issues are mental, and it falls on Rees. He should cater the offense to his strengths as a passer, but it's hard to when the guy under center can't make easy throws. But still, you have to try to set him up for success.

Typically. you want a coaching staff to elevate your young quarterback or your supposed face of the franchise to make things easier on your first-year staff, but nope. The Falcons have too much talent to be this much of a mess, and while Tommy Rees deserves some blame for being a Zac Robinson clone, it doesn't help that Michael Penix Jr. clearly isn't a franchise quarterback.

Add us as a preferred source on Google